DISCUSSION To you, what makes an album a ‘good’ album?

256wolfgang

Family Member
Jan 30, 2021
567
786
663
Real

&

Consistently good or consistent in tone or theme
Tone it doesnt really have to be consistent in theme as long as they don't go from saying sum bout don't kill yourself to saying if you don't have as much money me kill your self like a certain ! Album
 

cokey

Legendary Member
Donator
Author
Jan 30, 2021
5,521
15,806
1,118
Replayability, if it's meant to have a story then how well that story is portrayed with the lyrics and how many real life metaphors they can incorporate to say something in a different way. How much I enjoy it and how easily I can go back to it
 
  • RT
Reactions: pokken

pokken

Comfortable Member
Jun 30, 2022
366
294
183
Consistent theme, diverse production, proper mixing and maximum 2/3 "skips". A song i'd consider a skip is something just awful, not just a type of song (ie. acoustic) i dislike.
 

thisisamelobeat

Comfortable Member
Jul 16, 2021
223
291
283
Needs to have a compelling throughline/motif/theme that binds the album together. I hate when albums are just a bunch loosies slapped together, which is 90% albums dropping today. Even if executed poorly, its still better than no cohesion at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJ707
D

Deleted member 76796

Guest
when music makes me feel something, i know it's good
 

Budd Dwyer

Legendary Member
Feb 4, 2021
5,594
5,524
808
Hell
-No skips (skits don't count)
-Sustainability
-I need to be listening to this album all the time
 

declan

Legendary Member
Feb 15, 2021
2,307
7,206
683
Replay ability

Shit like die lit is near perfect considering I go back to so many of those songs damn near 5 years later now

low amount of skips too, but personally I don’t know any album that has zero skips (even my favorites I have songs I skip)
 

Draco

Comfortable Member
Feb 2, 2021
125
120
513
If about 30-40% of the tracks on an album are added to my library id say the album is good. To make a perfect album it would have to have around 90% of the tracks being added or i listen to it all the time front and back. For me Replay-ability is everything alot of amazing albums are good to listen once then i never comeback to it even if the music is well produced but lacks replay ability for me but other than that i have pretty low standards for a “good” album
 

Bubblegum

Family Member
Nov 25, 2021
599
725
313
Album follows a story and is very personal to the artist. Each song is a different chapter. For example, to pimp a butterfly.
 

mrfingers

Family Member
Feb 20, 2021
743
1
2,122
663
if it sounds good, it’s not that hard. i listen to music to enjoy it, not to give it a number
 
  • Like
Reactions: cokey

TotalAnarchy

Member
Nov 2, 2022
452
520
213
Views is good but definitely dropped heat after, not to mention honestly nevermind is a great summer album if you actually leave your fucking town

Bits and pieces. Aint heard a good drake project since IYRTITL views was all right but. Now nah
 

Bigfatmeanie44

Well-known Member
May 2, 2021
58
60
488
For me personally, I love when albums have a theme to it, like a story or a movie. I like when the tracks on an album sound nostalgic to make me feel something similar that I've felt before, whether that be sound or rhythm. I also love when the lyrics are detailed and talk about who, what, where, when and why cause I can also imagine it in my head and that creates a picture which makes it feel cinematic to me. I also love when albums have perfect instrumental choices for the theme they're going for, like the right sounds and the right tempo and tone of voice for the mood the artist was going for too.
Another thing that has replay value for me is whenever songs have moments, like "a synth lead only comes on during this part" or "this pause only happens here right before the verse" or "the 808 pattern changes here" I feel like those things matter because it will most likely make the listener want to go back and relisten to the song because of that. I think albums should be treated like a movie cause it's also very similar to exposition, rising action, climax, falling action, and conclusion. A few albums I can think of that have done AOTA pretty well is Rodeo, Blonde, CMIYGL, DAMN., I Decided, college dropout, CTRL, and testing just to name a few. I could play those albums front to back with no skips because it has special moments and doesn't feel to repetitive for me personally.
Another thing I love about songs is when it has references to something I know of or when they sample something I've heard before, because then it makes the song more special because I know what the artist was talking about or trying to recreate, same thing with topics as well.
I could go on forever about this but those are a few things that makes songs special to me, that was a good question and topic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: trilled
Top Bottom